Legendary Food Rivalries – NYC & Philly






In New York it’s pizza.  In Philly it’s a cheesesteak.  Seemingly every great city has it’s food rivalries and every local has his or her favorite.  How is anyone suppose to decide where to eat pizza in Manhattan when a simple google search (places = pizza+restaurant+new york, NY) turns of 81,300 pizza places!  Or the fact that every corner shop claims to be “The Original”, yet walk two blocks and you find — yet again, another “The Original”.

Having spent some time in these two metropolis destinations and being the food obsessed girl I am, I have a few hints.

Grimaldi’s vs. Lomardi’s (Infamous New York Brick Oven Pizza Rivalry)

Still fighting for the title of “The First Pizza in New York City” is the rival between Grimaldi’s & Lombardi’s.  Sometime in the year of 1905 these two establishments opened their doors baring a product that had not yet been introduced to the New Yorker.  As year’s past and the New Yorker’s heart for pizza grew big the argument for being the first boiled.  Honestly, I don’t think it’s ever been decided and the two legendary pizza joints will live on with their versions of “how it all happened”.

Grimaldi’s Pizzeria

Grimaldi's Under the Brooklyn Bridge
Grimaldi's Margherita Pizza

If you venture to the original Grimaldi’s under the Brooklyn Bridge you will not be disappointed.  A hint of old New York flows through the door with the sounds of Frank Sinatra and a sign that is posted on the door “NO SLICES”.  At Grimaldi’s they serve pizza as they do in Italy, by the pie.  They take pride in the use of fresh ingredients and claim their Margarita (a simple invention) is the best pie on the menu.  The restaurant is small and they and the original coal-oven heats the place up and emits a constant wave of fresh tomatoes, basil & garlic. Oh yeh — and the pizza.  Words cannot describe the melt in your mouth deliciousness that is a Grimaldi’s pizza.  I dare you to try…

Location:  Under the Brooklyn Bridge at 19 Old Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY 11201

Lombardi’s Pizzeria

Lombardi's 1905 dated Pizza Oven
Lombardi's Margherita Pizza

Located on the island of Manhattan, Lombardi’s Pizzeria, still cranks pizzas out everyday from their original oven built-in 1905.  The pizza joint at one time was practically a small narrow hallway, perhaps 12 feet wide — today they have expanded to the neighboring spaces.  You wind you way through door after door in awe of just how many rooms of people with sauce dribbling down their chins there are in this place.  The pizza sauce is sweet, the cheese is cooked perfectly and the pizza is served piping hot.  My only down side of the experience was that it felt touristy.

Location:  Corner of Spring and Mott Street just outside of Little Italy

Geno’s Steaks & Pat’s Steaks vs. Jim’s Steaks

An ancient rivalry exists between two legendary cheesesteak joints, Geno’s Steaks and Pat’s Steaks, years of battle have taken place in who has the brightest lights, the longest lines, and the freshest bread.  Both places are a must try once in my opinion if you live in or are visiting Philadelphia.  It is rumored to be best late in the night after a few drinks — the people watching epic.

However a rivalry Geno’s and Pat’s is, in my mind they are one in the same.  So instead of fueling the fire, I place them both up against Jim’s Steaks on South Street.

Geno’s & Pat’s

Geno's vs Pat's

Situated on a two directly adjacent corners, Geno’s Steaks and Pat’s Steaks, seem to not only be in competition for the best cheesesteak but for the best curb appeal.  Geno’s is DECKED out with neon lights and adorned with mouthful of cheesesteak snapshots of celebrities from Nicholas Cage to Vanna White. Rumor has it, this is curb appeal and claim to fame is Geno’s effort to make up for the fact that Pat’s steaks are better.  Pat’s corner home does not sport a giant neon sign of a cheesesteak, but it appeals to a crowd of it’s own.  On any given night lines are down the block, and people are gorging on cheesesteaks.

Location: East Passyuck at the corners of 9th & Wharton, Philadelphia, PA

Jim’s Steaks

A cheesesteak from Jim's

Jim’s Steaks has been grilling up onions and serving cheesesteaks with wiz, to the greater Philadelphia area since 1939.  The menu is simple – cheesesteaks and hoagies.  In my mind what make’s Jim’s special is the bread, it soaks up the juices of the steak and onions, without the becoming the dreaded soggy bread that breaks at the seam.  The steak is good quality, the onions have been on the grill for what seems like hours and the lines are half that of Geno’s & Pat’s.

Locations: 400 South Street; 431 North 62nd Street; Bustleton & Cottman Avenues; 469 Baltimore Pike, Springfield, PA



2 thoughts on “Legendary Food Rivalries – NYC & Philly

Add yours

  1. Patsy GRIMALDI opened in Brooklyn in 1990 or 1991. His uncle PATSY LANCIERI worked for LOMBARDIS along side with TOTONNOS back in 1905. LOMBARDIS was a grocery store that sold pizza. PATSY LANCIERI opened PATSY PIZZA in Harlem in 1933. I STILL THINK GRIMALDIS MAKE THE BEST PIZZA IN THE WORLD. BETTER THEN ITALY

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: